Independent retailers in the coastal town of Weymouth, Dorset, are increasingly troubled as plans unfold for yet another supermarket to open in their community. This new outlet will mark the fifth major national chain within a one square mile radius, intensifying competition and raising fears about the future of smaller, local businesses.
Currently, the Dorchester Road area of Weymouth is home to four supermarket chains: Morrisons, Sainsbury’s, Lidl, and Aldi. In 2027, a Marks and Spencer Food Hall is set to relocate from the town center to a site directly opposite Morrisons and Aldi, further concentrating supermarket offerings in the district.
Local traders have expressed deep concern about what they describe as “overkill,” worried that an abundance of big retailers could push independent shops out of the area. Deborah Strange of Howells Butchers, a family-run business serving the community for nearly 100 years, commented: “There are too many supermarkets in such a small space—it’s total overkill. From my shop window, I can see three of them.”
READ MORE: Families at Risk of Missing Out on Free Childcare Due to Limited Local Places
READ MORE: Bath Named World’s Most Beautiful City for Autumn
Despite the pressure, Strange remains confident, noting that Howells Butchers offers something unique: “We are a family-run, quality butcher with no competitors like us in Weymouth, so we rely on loyal customers and community support.”
Strange also voiced frustration about the impact these supermarkets have on the town center’s high street, which she feels is suffering as shoppers flock to larger stores with easier access and parking. “The town center needs sprucing up, but with excessive parking charges compounding the problem, fewer people choose to visit,” she added.
In contrast, Dorset Council maintains an optimistic view, emphasizing that new supermarkets will “energise the local economy.” A council spokesperson noted, “Attracting well-known brands encourages investment across various sectors. With a population nearing 54,000—plus an influx of visitors—there is space for both large national retailers and small independents to thrive in Weymouth.”
The debate highlights the challenge communities face in balancing economic development with preserving the unique character and diversity of their local shopping environments.