Castle Cary, a picturesque market town in Somerset, was recently named the best place to live in the UK by lifestyle website Muddy Stilettos. Praised for its independent shops, strong community spirit, and convenient travel links, the town topped a list of 300 locations. However, a popular YouTube channel, Turdtowns, has challenged this glowing reputation by calling out a significant downside: the town’s social atmosphere.
While admiring the town’s historic appeal and excellent railway connections, Turdtowns described the people of Castle Cary as “the most unfriendly bunch” they’ve encountered. Their claims go beyond typical antisocial behavior like littering or rudeness; instead, they encountered coldness that left a negative impression. Attempts at casual conversation were met with scowls, sneers, and icy stares rather than friendly greetings.
The YouTuber speculated that this frosty reception might stem from an influx of Londoners relocating to the area, changing the town’s dynamic. They noted that nobody returned a simple “good morning,” which starkly contrasted with the usually welcoming nature of Somerset.
READ MORE: Stunning Photos Capture Sunken Boats Being Towed Out of Bath
READ MORE: Somerset’s Dryad Gin Triumphs at Prestigious International Awards
Despite these criticisms, other sources paint a much warmer picture of Castle Cary. Choosewhere.com highlights the town’s historic architecture, tranquil countryside, and reputation as a charming and welcoming destination. They emphasize its suitability for relaxing getaways and exploration of Somerset’s rich heritage.
Muddy Stilettos itself celebrates Castle Cary’s shops, food scene, and strong sense of community, based on votes from their readers. Local residents also affirm the town’s appeal, taking pride in its attractions including the Market House, St Andrew’s Church, The Roundhouse, and unique boutiques.
Nearby, visitors and locals alike enjoy landmarks such as Glastonbury Tor, Stourhead Gardens, the Fleet Air Arm Museum, and The Newt in Somerset—with its renowned gardens, woodland trails, and cider experiences.
While Castle Cary’s community warmth may vary depending on who you ask, its quaint charm and quality of life remain undeniable. Whether it truly deserves its title as the UK’s best place to live may depend on your expectations of hospitality alongside picturesque surroundings.