A recent inquest into the death of Kelly Faiers in Somerset has sparked serious concerns from the senior coroner regarding the police response. Kelly, 61, was found dead in the home of Richard Scatchard, a convicted sex offender, in October 2023. The inquest, held on July 8, concluded that Kelly’s death was unlawful.
Kelly was involved in a secret relationship with Scatchard, 70, who hid it from his probation officers while Kelly kept it from her family. Scatchard had a history of serious offenses, including drugging and sexually assaulting women, and was on a life licence following a life sentence.
Senior coroner Samantha Marsh expressed deep concern about the police’s failure to arrest Scatchard immediately after Kelly’s death. Officers on the scene felt strongly that Scatchard should be taken into custody on suspicion of manslaughter, but their requests were overruled by a duty detective sergeant. The officers described feeling “confused, angry, and frustrated,” believing their concerns were dismissed despite clear warning signs.
READ MORE: Quiet Taunton Street Transformed into Construction Zone as Residents Endure Years of Disruption
READ MORE: Sex Offender Found Decomposed in Somerset Caravan Months After Death, Inquest Reveals
Ms. Marsh detailed that three officers—Pc Harris, Pc Fortune, and Sgt Whitehouse—had serious reservations based on Scatchard’s suspicious behavior and his dismissive attitude toward Kelly’s death by overdose involving sleeping tablets and alcohol. Trusting their instincts and training, they sought to arrest him, but were instructed not to by a higher-ranking officer. The coroner emphasised the challenge lower-ranked officers face in overriding orders from senior officers, especially within an institution built on hierarchy and respect for rank.
The coroner announced plans to write to Avon and Somerset Police Chief Constable Sarah Crew, urging her to review the case, particularly the decision-making processes and command structure that allowed such a critical decision to be blocked.
Following complaints from Kelly’s family, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) upheld three complaints against Avon and Somerset Police, while also acknowledging that other aspects of their service were deemed appropriate. The force has already issued an apology to Kelly’s family.
IOPC Director Derrick Campbell condemned the police’s handling of the case, noting that several officers’ actions fell below acceptable standards, though no disciplinary proceedings were warranted. Instead, those officers will undergo reflective practice reviews aimed at improving future conduct. Despite comprehensive investigations, the IOPC found no organizational learning needs, but the police are reviewing the report for any possible improvements.
An inquest into Richard Scatchard’s subsequent death, found in a caravan in April 2024, is scheduled for later this month.