The proposed demolition of the Church of the Good Shepherd, a rare example of 1960s brutalism in the Bath area, has sparked a heated debate among locals in the Northend area of Batheaston, Somerset. With the church no longer viable for regular use, the Diocese of Clifton plans to redevelop the site into housing, sparking objections from both supporters and detractors of the unique structure.
The church’s bold architectural style has divided opinion, with some praising it as an “important historical statement” and others denouncing it as an “eyesore.” Designed by Bath architect Martin Fisher, the building’s distinctive features and colorful interior have attracted both admirers and critics.
Supporters of the Church of the Good Shepherd argue that its demolition would erase an important piece of the village’s architectural heritage. They propose alternatives such as converting the building into dwellings to preserve its historic significance.
READ MORE: Council Puts Hold on Accepting Unaccompanied Asylum Seeking Children in Somerset Area
READ MORE: Latest Death and Funeral Notices in Somerset
On the other hand, opponents of the church view the proposed housing development as an opportunity to replace what they perceive as an architectural blemish with more fitting structures that blend seamlessly with the surrounding village landscape.
The controversy has led to a flurry of objections lodged with the local council, highlighting the deep-seated divisions within the community regarding the fate of the church and the proposed housing development.
Despite differing opinions on the church’s architectural merit, both supporters and opponents are united in their desire for a thoughtful and respectful approach to any future development on the site.