Plans for nearly 1,000 new homes in Yeovil face uncertainty after a judicial review into two major housing developments was granted permission by the High Court.
The Abbey Manor Group received outline planning approval from Somerset Council in October 2024 for the Up Mudford urban extension, north of Primrose Lane, which includes 765 homes alongside commercial spaces, a community hub, and an expansion of Primrose Lane Primary School. The council gave final approval to legal agreements in July, which also incorporated improvements to walking and cycling routes along the A359 Mudford Hill and Lyde Road.
However, progress on this development — along with the neighbouring Sock Hill project, approved on appeal for 252 homes — is now jeopardized after Mudford Parish Council secured the right to pursue a judicial review. This challenge reflects growing unease within the community at the scale and impact of the developments, which together could quadruple Mudford’s population from its current 339 homes in just a decade.
READ MORE: Weston-super-Mare Make History with First Ever FA Cup Third Round Appearance
READ MORE: Yeovil Town Secure Hard-Fought 2-0 Victory Away at Hartlepool United
Mudford Parish Council raised several concerns in their submission to the High Court, emphasizing potential risks overlooked in the council’s decision-making process.
James Cary, chairman of the Friends of Mudford Action Group (FOMAG), said, “We welcome the opportunity for Somerset Council’s planning processes to be thoroughly examined. Our group supports new housing, but any growth must respect community interests and fully consider impacts. This development is massive and will affect not only Mudford but neighbouring villages as well. We’re determined to ensure a proper review safeguards local communities.”
FOMAG member Robin Bowring highlighted the financial implications, estimating that a one-day hearing for the judicial review could cost up to £45,000, with an additional £35,000 if the Abbey Manor Group appeals the court’s ruling. Under the Aarhus Convention, Mudford Parish Council would have a limited cost liability of up to £10,000 if their challenge is unsuccessful.
Somerset Council confirmed it will contest the judicial review and has engaged legal counsel. The High Court is expected to set a date for the review early next year.
Meanwhile, the Sock Hill site was sold to Bloor Homes South West, which has experience developing housing projects like Somerton Mead. Bloor Homes plans to submit detailed design applications for Sock Hill in early 2026.
As these legal and planning battles unfold, the future of these substantial housing developments remains uncertain, placing hundreds of potential new homes — and the communities affected— in limbo.